Credit to Colin LooksBack
Thanks for 1K!
Part One
1: Alice Snuffleupagus (0:00)
2: Babytooth and The Fuzzy Funk (2:24)
3: Beautiful Day Monster (3:08)
4: Benny Rabbit (4:10)
5: Betty Lou (6:46)
6: Biff and Sully (9:17)
7: Bruno the Trashman (10:51)
8: Captain Vegetable
9: Chicago the Lion
10: Chip and Dip
Part Two
11: Colambo
12: Countess Dahling von Dahling
13: Cousin Monster
14: Deena and Pearl
15: Dexter
16: Don Music
17: Elizabeth
18: Earnestine and Brad
19: Farley
20: Forgetful Jones
Part Three
21: Frazzle
22: Harvey Kneeslapper
23: Professor Hastings
24: Herbert Birdsfoot
25: Joey and Davey
26: Kingston Livingston III
27: Lefty the Salesman
28: Leo the Party Monster
29: Little Bird
30: Little Chrissy
Part Four
31: Little Jerry
32: Mary Monster
33: Meryl Sheep
34: The Miami Mice
35: Mona, Frida and Juliette
36: Professor Nobel Price
37: Pladico Flamingo
38: Poco Loco
39: The Rockheads 
40: Roosevelt Franklin
Part Five
41: Roxy Marie
42: Ruby
43: Sam The Robot
44: Shelley the Turtle
45: Sherlock Hemlock
46: Simon Soundman
47: Sunny Friendly
48: Tough Eddie
49: Vincent Twice
50: Zostic
Links
Part One (   • 50 Retired Sesame Street Muppets (Par...  )
Part Two (   • 50 Retired Sesame Street Muppets (Par...  )
Part Three (   • 50 Retired Sesame Street Muppets (Par...  )