Madden NFL 24 is more of what you might expect if you've played Madden 23. While the game certainly boasts improvements over last year's offering including refined player models, visual design, animations, and extended variable controls, there's still a sensation that elements like the narratively bankrupt Superstar mode and the mixture of good minigames with lackluster ones in Franchise mode that spell stagnation for a major sports franchise like Madden.

There's not much that could convince gaming fans to spend their hardearned dollars on Madden NFL 24 if 23 is already in their library.